The third season of Netflix’s remake has a spritely energy and an appealing fresh-faced cast, but it lacks what made the long-running original so compelling

When it comes to remaking an old TV show, where do you draw the line between honouring the original and carving out a tone and style of your own? I’ll grant that Netflix’s Heartbreak High remake has its virtues, such as a sprightly energy and an appealing fresh-faced cast, but I’m not sure I can ever forgive the producers for taking such a blinged-out U-turn away from what made the long-running original so compelling.

The first Heartbreak High, which aired in the 1990s, had a thrilling near-verite realism and gritty, lived-in aesthetic that was perfectly befitting the authenticity of the characters, who were played by a widely diverse cast well before the diversity movement drew attention to popular culture’s long-entrenched whiteness.

Continue reading…

Published by Archie Watson on 24 March 2026. GEMHerald summarises reporting from other outlets and links to the original. Read our editorial policy and how we handle corrections.