I can accept the decision and authority of the appeal board, but I cannot accept that racist, sexist and homophobic language is excused as ‘commonplace’ in a ‘highly competitive’ game

The AFL appeal board’s decision to reduce the penalty handed to Lance Collard for allegedly using a homophobic slur, from nine games to four, is truly bewildering. If there is any positive to take from it, it is that I have never seen an AFL disciplinary hearing’s outcome so universally derided as this one, from all sides of politics and the sport.

Many individuals with a keen interest in the game have already shared their perspectives – including former AFLW player Kate McCarthy and reporter Marnie Vinall – and I echo their sentiments here. The appeal board’s decision leaves so much to be desired, and how Collard could receive a smaller penalty for his second offence than his first, is truly bizarre. It is only natural to be disappointed.

Mitch Brown is a Melbourne-based writer and former West Coast AFL footballer

Continue reading…

Published by Archie Watson on 23 April 2026. GEMHerald summarises reporting from other outlets and links to the original. Read our editorial policy and how we handle corrections.